Fake Bands, Reel Music Part 1 – Mockumentaries

Thursday, April 16, 2020, at 4 pm I’ll be hosting a special program for the WTJU Rock Marathon. I’ll be featuring music — and the artists that perform it — specifically for movies and TV shows.

Fictional musicians were a staple of the movie industry since the introduction of sound. Al Jolson played Jakie Rabinowitz, a fictionalized version of himself in 1927’s “The Jazz Singer.”

But with the advent of rock and roll, the concept of fictional artists grew and expanded. “Fake Bands, Reel Music” takes a look at how fictional groups really rocked.

Mockumentary Movies

When asked to name a mockumentary about music, many people respond, “Spinal Tap.” And rightly so. What made Carl Reiner’s 1984 film such a masterwork is the obsessive attention to detail. The movie features songs by the band from the early 60s, the Summer of Love, and into heavy metal. And each track is stylistically correct, sound exactly like the era its meant to invoke.

Guest, McKean, and Shearer would become part of a repertoire company who collaborated on a number of successful documentaries, such as “For Your Consideration” and “Best in Show.”

One of their films, “A Mighty Wind” (2003) follows three folk music groups as they gather for a tribute concert. The Folksmen (McKean, Guest, and Shearer) are based on the Kingston Trio. Their misguided attempt to go electric couples the Byrd’s jangly guitar with earnestly flawed lyrics.

Also featured are Eugene Levy and Catherine O’Hara as Mick and Mickey, an Ian and Sylvia soundalike.

John C. Reilly starred in 2007’s “Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story.” The film is a comedic take on documentaries about Johnny Cash, Roy Oberson, and other early sixties stars. The film’s unusual in that it mixes real celebrities (played by others) with the fictional musicians. Marshall Crenshaw and Van Dyke Parks contributed to the ostensively decade-spanning score.

The Rutles began as a skit created by Eric Idle (Monty Python) and Neil Innes (Bonzo Dog Band). This Beatles pastiche, with songs written by Innes, soon took on a life of its own. The group toured and had two UK hits.

Their 1978 TV movie “All You Need is Cash” is a satirical mockumentary of the Beatle’s career. Included in the cast was George Harrison as the interview, Ron Wood, John Belushi, and Dan Aykroyd. Mick Jagger, Paul Simon, and Roger McGough appear as themselves.

Small Screen Mockumentaries

“Documentary Now!” is a half-hour mockumentary series starring Fred Armisen and Bill Hader. Each episode parodies a famous documentary film, with a keen eye to detail.

“Gentle & Soft: The Story of the Blue Jean Committee” mirrors “History of the Eagles.” Armisen and Hader’s Blue Jean Committee is a perfect amalgam of the Eagles, America, Steely Dan, and the 70s So-Cal sound.

“Final Transmission” was based on the Talking Heads documentary “Stop Making Sense.” Armisen and Hade, with help from Maya Rudolph, nail the New Wave sound of their inspirations.

John Mulaney plays a version of Stephen Sondheim for “Original Cast Album: Co-Op.” It’s based on the documentary of the recordings sessions for “Company.” The episode features several Sondheim-like numbers that all ring true — and explain why “Co-Op” was canceled (according to the story) after one performance.

At the height of the boy band craze, MTV produced “2Gether,” a mockumentary TV movie. The title group was a by-the-numbers boy band, each member selected to fill an archetype; the heartthrob, the shy one, the cute one, the older brother, and the bad boy. 2Gether became a TV series, running on MTV for two seasons. They also released two albums.

All of the actors sang for the recordings.

Their single “The Hardest Part of Breaking Up (Is Getting Back Your Stuff)” charted on the Billboard Hot 100, and in 2000 they opened for Britany Spears on her summer tour.

Next: Fictional groups as characters


More Recent Posts

  • New Jazz & Blues News – 9/28/2021

    New Jazz & Blues News – 9/28/2021 New Jazz News: Andrew Cyrille – The News (ECM): “It would be tempting to say that, at 81, Andrew Cyrille has probably forgotten more than most drummers have ever learned about stretching tempo and creating space for improvisers to thrive in – that is, if it didn’t do […]

  • #ClassicsaDay #SymYesNo Week 3

    Tags: , , , , , , , ,

    For the month of September, the Classics a Day team chose a controversial theme. There is a small subset of symphonic works within the classical repertoire that appear misnamed. Most composers choose their titles carefully. But when the title runs counter to expectations, disagreements arise. What does the title “symphony” mean? Can a composition be […]

  • WTJU Jazz Profile: David Eisenman


    For decades, David Eisenman has served as WTJU’s Jazz Director, coordinating the department “as loosely as humanly possible,” as he puts it. He insists on responsible broadcasting, but with passion for the music and the love to share it. “Big in my playbook is diversity in the genre,” says David. “I have always attempted to make the umbrella […]

  • Stephen Pollock digs into Cherry Red, September 30

    Tags: , , , , ,

    Stephen Pollock, guitarist and leader of Cherry Red, the best Rolling Stones cover band in central Virginia, will join the Juddermeister on Induced to Judder September 30th at 9pm. Stephen will be promoting a special show the band will be performing paying tribute to Charlie Watts who recently passed away. This event will be held […]

  • WTJU Jazz Profile: Louise Largiader


    For Louise Largiader, WTJU was something of a slippery slope. First, she was a longtime listener. Then she started donating to the Marathons. Then answering phones during them. She says she never thought she’d be on the radio, but she made the jump to on-air DJ a few years ago. Here at the station, we’re so glad […]